13 Comments
User's avatar
David Coggins's avatar

Really great piece, David. As is your Esquire article. I was a big fan of Hemingway (his books) in my college days. He was a good writer.

Expand full comment
David Coggins's avatar

Thanks Dad!

Expand full comment
Brian Robinson, C Woodcock&Co's avatar

Again, well done. So many people project onto Hemingway what they wish him to be. And he is a great canvas on which to project as he is so many things simultaneously. Again, well done for highlighting this complexity with a good dose of fairness.

Expand full comment
CWCS's avatar

Last weekend, we hiked up Proctor Mountain just beyond the Hemingway memorial in Sun Valley. On the descent, my border collie jumped in Trail Creek which runs through the monument and reads:

“Best of all he loved the fall, the leaves yellow on the cottonwoods. Leaves floating on the trout streams and above the hills. The high blue windless skies, now he will be a part of them forever.”

Some older visitors looked on disapprovingly as she splashed and drank but in that moment I was very grateful for a beautiful autumn day - the wet dog appeared content as well.

Expand full comment
Dan's avatar

Really enjoyed the read David. Nicely done 👌🏼

Expand full comment
Emily Karcher's avatar

Really enjoyed the Esquire article. They owe you a boat!

Expand full comment
Bart S's avatar

Great article thanks David. I enjoyed the Esquire article also, I wish they'd commission writers like you to also write more fiction and sporting non-fiction. I think Hemingway's best book is Islands in the Stream, it feels like he got a bit of his experience and real perspective into it. Who knows?

Expand full comment
Daniel Aires's avatar

David; the Esquire piece is fantastic!

Expand full comment
Russell Smith's avatar

Complicated, indeed. I've never really been attracted to Hemingway as a writer, or liver of life for that matter. Something seemed off, some grounding, some rooting. Maybe as I get older, Gandhi's dictum that "my life is my message" becomes more apparent. And I feel less attracted by people who's life tell a message they probably wish it didn't.

Expand full comment
StewardCaTx's avatar

Great article - is this your first byline in Esquire?

Expand full comment
David Coggins's avatar

I wrote a guide to Naples for the Big Black Book years ago.

Expand full comment
StewardCaTx's avatar

Perhaps they’ll send you to Piggott, AR to write about Hemingway’s time there working for his in-laws

Expand full comment
Peter's avatar

thank you!

Expand full comment